New 2024 Rules on Descriptive and Generic Terms: Safeguarding Consumers and Upholding Trademark Integrity
In 2024, new regulations were introduced to address the registration and use of descriptive or generic terms in trademarks, reflecting a growing need to protect consumers from misleading brand practices and to maintain the integrity of the trademark system. These changes aim to clarify the boundaries between what can be trademarked and what must remain available for public use, ensuring that trademarks do not create unfair advantages or confusion in the marketplace.
Background: The Problem with Descriptive and Generic Terms
Trademarks serve as identifiers of the source of goods or services, helping consumers distinguish between different brands. However, not all terms are equally eligible for trademark protection. Descriptive terms, which directly describe a product’s characteristics (e.g., “creamy” for ice cream), and generic terms, which refer to the general category of a product (e.g., “soap” for soap), have traditionally been excluded from protection because they are necessary for fair competition and must remain available for all businesses to use.
Despite these principles, there have been ongoing challenges with businesses attempting to register descriptive or generic terms as trademarks, often leading to consumer confusion and unfair monopolies over common language. The new 2024 rules seek to address these issues head-on by tightening the criteria for trademark registration and use of such terms.
Key Changes in the 2024 Regulations
- Stricter Criteria for Registration of Descriptive Terms
- Heightened Examination Standards: The new rules require trademark examiners to apply more rigorous scrutiny to applications involving descriptive terms. To qualify for registration, a descriptive term must now demonstrate a high level of secondary meaning, proving that consumers associate the term specifically with the applicant’s brand rather than with the product type itself.
- Evidence Requirements: Applicants seeking to register a descriptive term must provide substantial evidence of secondary meaning, such as consumer surveys, extensive advertising campaigns, and long-term exclusive use of the term in a manner that distinguishes their goods or services.
- Absolute Prohibition on Generic Terms
- No Exceptions for Generics: The 2024 rules reinforce the absolute prohibition on registering generic terms as trademarks. This means that words commonly used to describe a type of product or service cannot be monopolized by any one business, ensuring that competitors can freely use these terms to describe their own offerings.
- Monitoring and Enforcement: Trademark offices are now tasked with more actively monitoring the marketplace to prevent the misuse of generic terms in branding and advertising. This includes taking action against businesses that attempt to enforce rights over unregistrable generic terms.
- Addressing Potential Consumer Misleading
- Consumer Protection Focus: The new regulations emphasize the importance of preventing consumer confusion or deception, particularly in cases where descriptive or generic terms are used in ways that might mislead the public. For instance, using a descriptive term in a manner that suggests a product is the only one of its kind or superior in some way without substantiation will be closely scrutinized.
- Transparency in Branding: Companies are encouraged to use clear and accurate branding that does not exaggerate the qualities of their products or suggest exclusivity based on a trademarked term that is merely descriptive.
- Increased Challenges and Oppositions
- Streamlined Opposition Process: The 2024 rules include provisions for a streamlined process through which competitors and consumer advocacy groups can challenge the registration or use of descriptive or generic terms as trademarks. This allows for quicker resolution of disputes and reduces the likelihood of such trademarks slipping through the cracks.
- Expanded Standing for Opponents: The new regulations expand the criteria for who can file an opposition, allowing not only direct competitors but also industry groups and consumer organizations to challenge potentially misleading trademarks.
- Guidelines for Businesses
- Best Practices for Descriptive Branding: Businesses are provided with new guidelines on how to use descriptive terms in branding without infringing on trademark rules. These guidelines encourage the use of more distinctive, creative elements in branding while allowing descriptive terms to serve their natural function of informing consumers.
- Clearer Path to Registration for Unique Marks: The regulations also outline clearer pathways for businesses to successfully register trademarks that are inherently distinctive or have acquired distinctiveness over time, avoiding reliance on descriptive or generic terms.
Implications for Businesses and Consumers
The 2024 rules bring several important implications for both businesses and consumers:
- Impact on Trademark Strategies
- Reevaluating Brand Names: Businesses will need to reassess their current and future trademark strategies, particularly if they rely on descriptive terms. Brands that currently hold descriptive trademarks may face challenges if they cannot prove the required level of secondary meaning under the new rules.
- Increased Litigation Risks: With stricter scrutiny and enhanced opposition mechanisms, businesses may see an increase in challenges to their trademarks, particularly if their marks are perceived as descriptive or generic.
- Benefits for Consumers
- Reduced Confusion: Consumers stand to benefit from these regulations as they reduce the likelihood of being misled by brands that use descriptive terms to suggest false exclusivity or superior qualities.
- Access to Common Terms: The protection of generic terms ensures that consumers can rely on clear, common language to compare products and make informed purchasing decisions without being swayed by trademarks that monopolize everyday words.
- Encouraging Innovation in Branding
- Push for Distinctiveness: The stricter rules are likely to encourage businesses to invest more in creating distinctive, memorable brand identities that stand out in the marketplace, rather than relying on descriptive terms that offer little in terms of unique brand recognition.
Conclusion
The 2024 trademark law changes regarding descriptive and generic terms represent a significant shift towards greater consumer protection and a more equitable trademark system. By tightening the criteria for trademark registration and enforcing stricter rules against misleading use of descriptive and generic terms, these regulations help maintain a competitive marketplace where language remains a shared resource and brands compete on the strength of their distinctiveness.
For businesses, these changes mean a renewed focus on innovation in branding and a careful approach to trademark strategy. For consumers, they promise clearer choices and reduced confusion, ultimately leading to a more transparent and fair marketplace. As these rules take effect, both businesses and consumers will need to stay informed and adaptable to navigate the evolving trademark landscape.
Tracy Jong is a Senior attorney at Evans Fox LLP with 30 years of experience focusing her practice in business law, intellectual property and licensing for alcohol and cannabis. Tracy Jong is a member of the New York Bar and is a registered attorney at the United States Patent and Trademark Office. She can be reached at Tjong@EvansFox.com.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
The content has been prepared for informational purposes only; it should not be construed as legal advice, does not create or constitute an attorney-client relationship, and readers should not act upon it without seeking professional counsel.